Four men who allegedly set ablaze three trucks at Ashys service station in Bulawayo’s Nkulumane 12 suburb during the Shutdown protests had their application for discharge denied.
The quartet on Monday, through their legal representatives from Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights applied for discharge at the close of the state case.
Tafadzwa Mhou (26) a soldier, Washington Chididi (26), Dexter Mungwadi (23) and Dalumizi Ndlovu (26) appeared before Western Commonage court magistrate Tancy Dube facing a charge of public violence.
They were part of the mob that protested on January 15 during the stay away skirmishes which were marred with vandalism of property and looting.
The state dismissed the application and magistrate Dube remanded the four in custody to February 13.
The Defence council has since made an urgent chamber application to the High Court after another bid to have the quartet released on bail was denied.
Another co-accused Ntandoyenkosi Moyo (27), who is also a soldier was allegedly shot in the abdomen by the owner of the garage Mr Ashton Mpofu during the protests.
He is currently receiving treatment at Mater Dei Hospital under police guard.
The quartet through their lawyers, argued that the state had failed to provide compelling evidence linking them to the crime.
“Your Worship, this court hasn’t been helped with any incriminating evidence. The evidence presented to this court does not at all show how the arrested people were identified and linked to the offense alleged. As such may the court discharge them as they are being held under ill-fitting conditions,” said the lawyer.
Constable Marufu, the arresting officer, testified that he only arrested three people after getting an instruction from his superior.
He said at the time of arrest only three people were in the car and has no knowledge of the arrest of the fourth person.
“We mounted a stop and search roadblock. I stopped them but they identified themselves as soldiers. Since there was a lot of commotion going on I assumed they were there on duty so I let them pass.
“However as they were about to leave I got a message from my superior that they should not be let to pass as they were being sought by the police in connection with the protests. That was when I ordered them to park their vehicle and subsequently arrested them, ” he said.
The Investigative officer Mgcini Sibanda told the court that the accused persons gave various alibis in an effort to evade being linked to the offense.
“Mhou said he arranged with Ndlovu and Moyo to meet at Ashys and deliberate on how to get to work since there was no transport. They alleged that while together, Moyo got shot by a stray bullet hence they called Mungwadi to come and assist them with transportation to the hospital,”said Sibanda.
He confirmed to the court that he did not follow up with police station and barracks hospital to check if the arrested people’s alibis were genuine.
Prosecuting, Thembeni Mpofu said accused persons were part of the people who were protesting at Ashys garage.
“In an effort to disperse the crowd, Ashton Mpofu armed himself with his 303 rifle and started shooting in the air. The accused were undeterred and kept advancing towards the garage shop.
“The accused went to some parked vehicles where they set ablaze three trucks. Moyo was shot in the abdomen and was bungled into a Nissan Note before they drove him to 1 Brigade to seek medical attention,” the court heard.